Hi,
I have the Flipsky 75100 Pro v2 with ALU PCB. I have followed [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QaVPISP8BF4]( Ludwig Bre’s VESC Setup video) for setting it up. It seemed to work OK (for my bench test), but the brake wasn’t working. I tried increasing the brake and regen limits to about 50%, but without success. I then noticed it was running 75_300_R2 VESC FW, and not 75_100_V2. Various online sources contradict each other on which FW I should use.
- Which FW is recommended to use? 75_300_R2 or 75_100_V2
- Would running 75_100_V2 fix the brake issue? If not, any ideas?
If it helps for diagnosis I am using the Flipsky 6384 140KV motor with the above on 12s4p (no BMS)
If you followed my video on the input setting step, the brake will only be applied very lightly if you let go of throttle, basically just enough to come to a Stillstand in 1-2s
You will have to modify the timing parameters so at no throttle or depending on your remote if you apply the brake you see -100% range I think however that may lead to problems when starting vesc, since it does not like to start at a non-0% input
So most likely you will need a remote that features a separate brake button
Thanks for the quick response. If I understand correctly in your video at 19:08 https://youtu.be/QaVPISP8BF4?t=1148 you are applying a 0.6% braking at zero throttle? I need to time mine properly, but it seemed more like 4-5s. I will try with brake enabled and disabled and see if there is any difference in time to stop.
Basically yes
Another thing to keep in mind: if you apply full brake all the time, the VESC will flow that current you set through the motor all the time - from connecting the battery until you are in the water and the motor finally gets cooling - this may harm the motor and for sure wastes energy
Maybe rpm-control with PID will solve your problem, this way at 0 Throttle the vesc will do everything to reach 0rpm. Meaning it will fully brake a spinning prop, and then stop the brake once it is at 0 rpm
However I find this mode rather unstable and fiddly
Duty control could also do that - not 100% sure though