3D-printed folding propeller

EFOIL.builders Propulsion System (Motor, Gears)
106

Some interesting figures comparing toughness of ePLA-ST compared to regular PLA:

  • Elongation at break for PLA-ST is 90%. Regular PLA is 5%, PLA+ is 29%. PLA-ST is much less brittle.
  • Izod Impact Strength (receiving a sharp blow): PLA-ST absorbs 63 KJ/m2, where regular PLA is only 4.2 KJ/M2 and PLA+ is 7 KJ/M2. ePAHT-CF absorbs 12.74 KJ/M2 (nylon with carbon fibre). PETG is around 8 KJ/M2. Therefore PLA-ST is 10x as impact tough as other PLA filament.
  • The bending strength of PLA-ST is 44 MPa, compared to PLA 90 Mpa and PLA+ 75 MPa, so it’s not as strong overall.

If it is the impact/shock of the propellor opening that breaks it, then PLA-ST might be a lot more durable. It’s not very expensive, I’ll probably give it a try when I put together my assist build.

4 Likes
107

The problem with aluminum casting is the thickness of the blades. it is difficult to have a good result if the thickness is less than 2.5 mm

108

This problem of the aluminium casting (mnimal thickness of 2.5 mm) can be easily eliminated by first casting the blade in a rough shape, then precisely machining this rough casting on a CNC mill. I believe this technology of making a folding propeller is commonly used. I guess the hardest part would be finding someone in the EU to produce such castings.

109

Would be as easy to mill the blade from a bloc. Never easy to register on a cast. Also an aluminium cast will never have the mechanical property of a part milled from a billet

1 Like
110

I would also like to clarify that propeller casting (and any subsequent precision machining on a CNC mill, if necessary) has been used, I believe, for many decades for 99% of all propellers produced in the world (except for RC model propellers). And it’s made of every kind of metal alloy that comes to mind - aluminum alloys, bronze alloys, steel alloys, … In addition, it is also worth considering that separate blades for the folding propeller (for e-foil propulsion) can be successfully made from high quality plastic, simply by casting without pressure. In this case, it is possible to produce the mould very accurately and very cheaply, e.g. using a 3D printer.

111

any updates on the testing of this optimized prop?

112

My final design works for me since more than 10 Sessions without any problems:

10 Likes
113

Great info everybody, (thanks to SoEfoil for pointing me in this direction) this is just the thing I’m looking for.
Ive started a thread to create a budget designed and produced bronze folding propeller for less than 200€ to see if anyone on the forum would be interested.
https://foil.zone/t/community-designed-produced-folding-propellor/16532/3

The work you guys have already done is great and answered some of the questions I have about the project. I do have some more though if you don’t mind?

Is it really necessary for a metal version (apart from the ‘BLING!’ factor)? I saw some durability issues early on but it seems some of you have your 3D printed props pretty much dialled in now?

Im also interested in what the most common motor attachment is for the hub, (80100, Flipsky etc) so we can cast the most popular hubs first and get a wider data pool of testing for optimising blades.
Last question for now, would there be anyone with data logging capabilities be willing to test prototypes? Preferably in Europe to save time/money on shipping.
Thanks everybody
mani

114

Sorry, I forgot one thing.
Id just like to check with @leachim and @superlefax if its ok to adapt and cast in metal your 3D models.
mani

115

Superlefax has set a store up based on his folding prop:

116

How was the durability of the SLS nylon for prop blades?

117

Hay Mani, have you found a way to cast one of the folding props and test different hubs ?